McCarthy and Hayes coined the term "qualification problem" in 1969. It is challenging to identify whether or not a machine is intelligent, known as the "qualification problem" in AI. Different people define intelligence differently. 

Researchers of qualification problem

We can trace the first published use of the term "qualification problem" to Hayes in 1973. In his 1977 presentation on the missionaries and cannibals dilemma, McCarthy introduces the qualification problem and examines how a boat could be prevented from crossing the river. McCarthy (1980) and Hayes (1971) discuss the qualifying dilemma. For describing qualifications, Ginsberg and Smith (1987) suggest using state restrictions; F. Lin and Reiter (1994) refer to them as "qualification constraints."

The question could be phrased as, "How do I overcome the obstacles preventing me from reaching my goal?" It's related to the frame problem and sits on the flip side of the coin from the ramifications. As a motivating example, John McCarthy offers the following scenario: it is difficult to list the circumstances that may prevent a robot from executing its normal role.

Qualification problem

The qualification problem in AI refers to the challenge of testing a machine's intelligence. It is because there is no agreed-upon definition of intelligence, and hence individuals may have varying ideas of what constitutes intelligent behaviour. The problem is made worse because it's hard to stay up with the latest developments in AI technology. As a result, it can be challenging to identify if a machine is smart.

Think of an autonomous vehicle programmed to read road signs and obey traffic signals. The car's AI has been fed a massive dataset of road signs and traffic lights, along with instructions for what to do in each scenario (e.g., stop at a red light, yield to people at a crosswalk). But what if the car runs into something that wasn't in its training dataset? What if a construction worker uses hand signals to guide traffic or a police officer waves the vehicle to a stop?

Such circumstances can confound the self-driving car's AI system because it has never seen anything like them. The AI Qualification Problem can be seen here in plain sight. Serious mistakes or mishaps may occur if the system cannot generalise its knowledge to new contexts. Therefore, solving the Qualification Problem is crucial for the security and dependability of AI systems.

Causes

Many different things could lead to "qualification problems" in artificial intelligence. One possible explanation is that AI was improperly trained due to inaccurate or incomplete data. It might cause problems when the AI is applied to new data, leading to incorrect predictions or choices. The lack of sufficient data to train the AI could also be to blame. It might result in overfitting when the AI learns too much about the training data and becomes overly particular. The AI's design or programming can cause issues with certification. If the AI isn't trained to handle specific facts or situations, it may not work.

Applications

The Qualification Problem in AI is an all-encompassing problem that can appear in different contexts where AI is used. Some typical instances of the Qualifying Issue are as follows:

• Diagnostic errors or omissions made by healthcare providers due to AI's inability to generalise its knowledge to novel settings are standard. For instance, a skin cancer-trained AI system may have trouble diagnosing a rare disease it has never seen before.
• Self-driving cars may make mistakes or have accidents if subjected to settings they have never seen before, such as severe weather or a construction zone.
• Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems may have trouble understanding speech in loud surroundings or from speakers with accents unfamiliar to the ASR system.
• AI systems used in robotics may need help adjusting to new settings, which could cause the robot to make mistakes when navigating obstacles or performing new tasks.
• Detecting fraud: AI systems deployed for this purpose may not be able to spot completely novel fraud schemes.
• AI systems employed in natural language processing may need help grasping the meaning of language in some contexts, resulting in mistakes in translation or interpretation.

Image source: Unsplash